Source 1: Toxic Psychiatry (Book)
1: Provide a Complete Citation for the Source: Breggin, P. R. (1991). Toxic Psychiatry. New York: St. Martin's Griffin. In Text Citation: (Breggin 1991)
2. In what ways are the information, ideas and arguments in the source relevant to your research writing project? Dr. Breggin’s book is all about his experiences in the field of Psychiatry since the 1950s before the big drug movement for mental illness and everything to follow. His arguments and research are sound therefore this book will be crucial to my research.
3. Is the line of argument in the source sound and well supported? In what ways can you use it in your project? Everything in this book is well supported. I can use the different stories and research to support my argument that Psychiatrist are basically corrupted by the pharmaceutical drug companies and the Doctors are doing more harm that any good to their patients.
4. What have you learned about the author and publisher that would lead you to accept, question or reject the line of argument presented in the source? The author of the book was a Harvard graduate and one of the leading and respected doctors in the Psychiatric specialty. The publisher is also very well-known and respected therefore I believe this book to be of great value.
5. In what ways does the publication date of the source affect your judgment of its usefulness for your project? The publication date does worry me some since it was written in 1991. But he provides a great detailed background of how he witnessed psychiatry becoming what it is today. It also shows that this problem was well known at the time it was published and is still going on today.
6. In what ways does the comprehensiveness of the source affect your judgment of its usefulness for your project? Dr. Breggin explains in a way that anyone who does not have a background in psych can understand. I was worried that some of these books would be above my level but it is really easy to follow.
7. In what ways does the genre of the source affect your judgment of its usefulness for your project? This genre is described as a “myth shattering expose”, therefore it is not a novel, or autobiographical type of book. It is a book that just lays the facts out there for people to read and decide how to go on from there.
8. In what ways could this source help you achieve your purpose and address the needs and interest of your readers? I think this source will help me explain the complicated relationships between the drug companies, FDA, Doctors and patients easily to show my readers how bad things have gotten, and how easily it would be to fix this situation and save lives at the same time.
9. How are you likely to use this source in your project? So far from my reading of this book I think it will probably be my biggest “go-to” for my project. It is filled with a lifetime of personnel experiences of learning, helping, teaching, and practicing psychiatry. Dr. Breggin’s profound knowledge on the subject really helps support why he does not believe in prescribing medications for mental illness and just how far down the rabbit hole psychiatry is compared to any other mental health practice.
Source 2: Happy Pills: From Miltown to Prozac (Book)
1. Herzberg, D. (2009). Happy Pills in America: From Miltown to Prozac. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. In Text Citation: (Herzberg 2009)
2. Herzberg book is focusing more on the actual medications and how since their existence has drastically affected and changed our society. I have just received the book today so I will have to dive more into it to get a better grasp on the subject matter.
3. One third of this book is notes and references to show just how well the information stated is supported. So I think, yes, this source is very well supported.
4. The author has many reviews of Journals for History and Medicine singing his praises for his book. Therefore with that much support I would have to think it is a trustworthy source.
5. The publication date is fairly recent so it will help me with most recent arguments for my topic.
6. While I have not read very much into this book, the pictures of ad campaigns and charts and graphs will be vital in understanding what the author is trying to get across to the readers.
7. This genre is specifically aimed at the different types of drugs prescribed for different disorders. This will help me prove that the drugs do more harm than good to the patients because there is no proof that a disorder exists and there is proof that the drugs do cause harm to the brain etc. So this book will probably have me focus more on that than any other part of it.
8. This book will help support my topic that the doctors and FDA are in the pocket of the pharmaceutical companies.
9. I am very likely to use this source in my project because it is full of a wealth of knowledge pertaining to the types of medications/drugs used in psychiatry.
Source 3: Generation Rx: How Prescription Drugs Are Altering American Lives, Minds, and Bodies. (Book)
1. Critser, G. (2005). Generation Rx: how prescription drugs are altering American lives, minds, and bodies. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company. In Text Citation: (Critser, 2005)
2. Critser’s book is about the different pharmaceutical companies and their strategies legal or not to advertise and get their drugs out there. It also discussed how the people of America have begun feeling “entitled” to these drugs whether they are needed or not.
3. The book seems to be well supported; again I just received this one so I haven’t been able to read into it yet. I will mostly likely use this one to support my arguments about the drug companies themselves.
4. The author, Greg Critser, is a longtime chronicler of the modern pharmaceutical industry. His essays and columns on the subject have appeared in Harper’s Magazine, USA Today, The Wall Street Journal, and the Los Angeles Times just to name a few. Therefore it seems that he is well educated in the subject so his research should be true.
5. Again, the publication date is fairly recent so I feel I can trust the arguments made will still be valid.
6. Hopefully the book it easy to comprehend, If the text is not, I will not use it as much for my sources as I would if I completely understood everything in the book.
8. This book could help me a lot with providing insight to the pharmaceutical companies themselves and how they are ran.
9. I will most likely use this source along with the other 2 books as my main sources.
Source 4: Psychiatry Making a Killing (Documentary)
1. Proper source to follow as I am still waiting for my copy of this documentary in the mail: Making a Killing: The Untold Story of Psychotropic Drugging (DVD)
2. This documentary is what created an interest for me in this topic. I had to watch it for another class. At the time I did not realize that it was produced by the CCHR, who are a scientology based group that believes psychiatry is the “root of all evil”. So while I now know it is a very biased documentary I still plan to use it to find the truths within it based on the doctors and stories behind it.
3. I believe most of the material in the documentary is sound and supported it is simply a matter of getting threw the distinct bias of the documentary and looking at it in a more scientific way to show the damage that is done to the “normal” people by the drugs and drug administration. Please do not get me wrong, I do believe there are people with mental illnesses that do need some medical intervention and in no way should they not be able to get the help that they need.
4. Again, the publisher is the CCHR, which makes this not only a documentary but propaganda. I will need to find the truths in the film.
5. (I still do not have the actual DVD yet). I believe that the publication date was made in the late 90s-Early 2000s so it stands to reason most of the information given is up to date for that time.
6. This source is very easy to comprehend and follow; it is dialed down to a level a child could understand. Again, it is finding the facts vs. the propaganda to evaluate the real problems.
7. The genre is meant to be a documentary but it is formed on a very biased opinion so it will be harder to use as a source, but not impossible.
8. This source is very easy to use to get the readers engrossed in the topic. It is what made me so interested in the topic of Psychiatry.
9. I will be using this as a source in my paper, but I will only use the factual evidence provided.
Source 5: “Concepts of Modern Psychiatry” (Lecture)
1. Sullivan, H. S. (2012). Conceptions of Modern Psychiatry: The first William Alanson White Memorial Lectures. Psychiatry: Interpersonal & Biological Processes, 3-17. In Text Citation (Sullivan 2012).
2. The source is relevant because it is a Lecture found in the OC Library’s database on Modern Psychiatry. And should provide a different view on today’s psychiatry verses the popular negative opinions on the subject.
3. This article is about psychiatry. I have not read the entire article yet, but there is an abundant number of notes on each page so I believe it is a well-supported argument.
4. Because this article is written by psychiatrist who believe and prescribe based on today’s psychiatric methodology I believe that I will use this article more on the premise on the idea psychiatrist believe they are doing it the right thing for their patients.
5. The publication date is only a year old therefore I think it will give me an up to date idea on the subject.
6. This article seems particularly harder to follow that the other sources I have. I will most likely have to go over and over it to truly comprehend what is being said.
7. The genre is an academic lecture, so I will have to read it and try not to see threw the different bias that is sure to be in the document. Again I will be using this as a template to form my argument against it.
8. This source could help me support my thesis based on the arguments made in it and to keep my paper interesting for my readers.
9. I hope to use this source a lot for my paper, but due to the comprehension factor, I might have to go into different sources to find another article to better form my argument against.
Excellent work!
ReplyDelete