Friday, April 26, 2013

Chapter 12: Developing Your Argument 04/26/13

            To develop your argument you must first determine your position on an issue. For example, my topic is Psychiatry and the Psychotropic drug industry (to include FDA and Doctors). Forming my argument to include all of these aspects is particularly hard for me and my topic because there is so much I want to cram into my thesis. So my thesis will be more broad, basically I am against the over use of every issue in my topic.
                Bedford says to develop a strategy to support your thesis statement. Step 1 is to choose reasons to support your thesis statement. The book suggests brainstorming or free writing to generate ideas. For my paper I will divide it up into sections to hit each of my arguments for the different causes of overuse of psychotropic drugs. When free writing Bedford suggest following some of their guidelines listed such as; readers of reflective documents (academic essays) will expect you to focus on a specific topic (so watch out for those left field tangents). Step 2 is selecting evidence to support your reasons.  We have already gone over a lot of chapters for finding good evidence such as peer reviewed journals, or doing field research as Ch. 10 discusses. Step 3 is to decide how to appeal to your readers. This is something I will have to focus on for my research paper because it is so easy just to go off and make psychiatrist sound like medieval voodoo type doctors (these two do not go together, just making a point) who have no business practicing medicine. When sometimes I truly believe they can help some people with medication. I guess I am trying to say not to sound too biased, if you don’t listen to other arguments, and you are only one-sided then your point is usually mute. Step 3 talks about how to present your argument to your audience in a proper way, for example: Appeal to Authority, Appeal to Emotion, Appeal to Principles, Values and Beliefs, Appeal to Character, and Appeal to Logic.
                Another great suggestion is to avoid distraction or “a red herring”, if your document is organized well this should help with avoiding that. Also don’t stack the deck. This refers to only writing and supporting one side of an argument it leads the reader to believe you are hiding something. I have come across that in the documentaries for my topic, and that is exactly how it made me feel. All I wanted to do was research and see where they got their information and what they were leaving out.  This chapter will be very important to my paper because it hits on exactly what I will need to do and not to do to support my argument.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Working Bibliography 04/24/13

Working Bibliography
1) Barker, Phil, and Poppy Buchanan-Barker. "First, Do No Harm: Confronting The Myths Of Psychiatric Drugs." Nursing Ethics 19.4 (2012): 451-463. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “The enduring psychiatric myth is that particular personal, interpersonal and social problems in living are manifestations of ‘mental illness’ or ‘mental disease’, which can only be addressed by ‘treatment’ with psychiatric drugs. Psychiatric drugs are used only to control ‘patient’ behavior and do not ‘treat’ any specific pathology in the sense understood by physical medicine. Evidence that people, diagnosed with ‘serious’ forms of ‘mental illness’ can ‘recover’, without psychiatric drugs, has been marginalized by drug-focused research, much of this funded by the pharmaceutical industry. The pervasive myth of psychiatric drugs dominates much of contemporary ‘mental health’ policy and practice and raises discrete ethical issues for nurses who claim to be focused on promoting or enabling the ‘mental health’ of the people in their care.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR] .
2) Breggin, P. R. (1991). Toxic Psychiatry. New York: St. Martins Press.
Summary (From Book): “In this searing, myth-shattering exposé, psychiatrist Peter R. Breggin, M.D., breaks through the hype and false promises surrounding the "New Psychiatry" and shows how dangerous, even potentially brain-damaging, many of its drugs and treatments are. He asserts that: psychiatric drugs are spreading an epidemic of long-term brain damage; mental "illnesses" like schizophrenia, depression, and anxiety disorder have never been proven to be genetic or even physical in origin, but are under the jurisdiction of medical doctors; millions of schoolchildren, housewives, elderly people, and others are labeled with medical diagnoses and treated with authoritarian interventions, rather than being patiently listened to, understood, and helped. Toxic Psychiatry sounds a passionate, much-needed wake-up call for everyone who plays a part, active or passive, in America's ever-increasing dependence on harmful psychiatric drugs.”
*      This book is amazing, and full of true stories to refer back to. A Psychiatrist letting out all of the dark secrets.
3) Critser, G. (2005). Generation Rx: how prescription drugs are altering American lives, minds, and bodies. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Summary (From Book): “Greg Critser's brilliantly incisive Generation Rx shows how shockingly little we know about the prescription drugs we take and the hazards they may pose to our health. Americans are prescribed more drugs today than ever before, and the pharmaceutical industry has gained tremendous financial power and political clout. Drawing on exclusive access to the strategists, scientists, and current and former heads of GlaxoSmithKline, Eli Lilly, Merck, and other drug giants, Critser chronicles the transformation of big pharma from onetime lumbering medical conglomerate to media-savvy consumer enterprise. He also reveals the direct and indirect consequences for our health, among them increased incidence of damage to major organs, unprecedented medication use by the very young and very old, and the emergence of polypharmacy, in which various drugs taken together can unleash unanticipated, and often deadly, effects. Generation Rx urges all of us to think about the price we pay, as a society and with our own bodies, for our chronic use of prescription drugs.”
4) Docksai, Rick. "Long-Term Risks Of Psychiatric Drugs." Futurist 47.3 (2013): 12-14. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “The article discusses research into the long term side effects of psychiatric drugs such as antidepressants and antipsychotics. Brain and body chemistry changes, drug prescriptions in the U.S. and Great Britain, and issues such as over prescription are discussed, as well as the attitudes of psychiatrists such as Richard Friedman and Peter Breggin. Side effects such as brain-tissue shrinkage, bone fractures, and tardive dyskinesia are discussed, as well as quality of life considerations for mentally ill people.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
*      I will use this article a lot for my paper because it refers to Breggin, Author of Toxic Psychiatry (repetition!!!) and is about “Over prescription” which is one of the main arguments for my paper.
5) Goldman, David Eckstein. "Mental Illness, Medicine And Law." Journal Of Legal Medicine 31.1 (2010): 163-170. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary:
“The article reviews the book "Mental Illness, Medicine and Law," edited by Martin Lyon Levine.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
*      This article is full of the legal terminology needed for my research paper to be sound.
6) Gottstein, James B. "Ethical And Moral Obligations Arising From Revelations Of Pharmaceutical Company Dissembling." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 12.1 (2010): 22-29. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “The article reports on pharmaceutical companies' fraud and manipulation and their impact on psychiatrists, psychologists, and social workers' ethical obligation. U.S. Senator Charles Grassley has reportedly exposed psychiatric opinion leaders for secretly and illegally taking large sums of money from drug companies in exchange for promoting their psychiatric drugs. The author provides a list of those involved, and concludes that psychiatrists, psychologists and social workers are ethically obliged to lead the way toward stopping the fraud.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR] .
7) Grekin, Emily R. et al. "Psychotropic Drug Use Among College Students: Patterns Of Use, Misuse, And Medical Monitoring." Journal Of American College Health 59.7 (2011): 658-661. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “Objective: To assess whether college students who use psychotropic drugs are (1) aware of potential side effects, (2) appropriately monitored by prescribing physicians, and (3) taking medications as prescribed. Participants: Fifty-five college students, currently taking psychotropic medications, were recruited between Summer 2008 and Fall 2009. Methods: Participants were given interviews assessing (1) interactions with prescribing physicians, (2) patterns of psychotropic drug use, and (3) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) substance use disorders. Results: Twenty-five percent of participants did not remember being assessed for suicidal ideation. A large number of participants took their medications in different quantities or frequencies than prescribed and 35% of participants met DSM criteria for substance dependence. Conclusions: Many students are misusing psychotropic medications and this misuse is not being communicated with prescribing physicians.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR] .
8) Hagen, Brad F., Gary Nixon, and Tracey Peters. "The Greater Of Two Evils? How People With Transformative Psychotic Experiences View Psychotropic Medications." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 12.1 (2010): 44-59. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “The article reports on a qualitative study that shows the potentially transformational nature of psychotropic medication. Some participants interviewed believe psychotropics should be used only in crisis situations, while others speak of the drugs' considerable limitations or say their use is never justified. Reports of physical, cognitive, emotional, and spiritual harm are made. Practitioners are encouraged to study the literature on the lack of actual effectiveness and side effects of the drugs. Data analysis and ethical considerations are taken up.”
9) Herzberg, D. (2009). Happy Pills in America: From Miltown to Prozac. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Summary (From Book): “David Herzberg addresses these questions by tracing the rise of psychiatric medicines, from Miltown in the 1950s to Valium in the 1970s to Prozac in the 1990s. The result is more than a story of doctors and patients. From bare-knuckled marketing campaigns to political activism by feminists and antidrug warriors, the fate of psychopharmacology has been intimately wrapped up in the broader currents of modern American history. Beginning with the emergence of a medical marketplace for psychoactive drugs in the postwar consumer culture, Herzberg traces how "happy pills" became embroiled in Cold War gender battles and the explosive politics of the "war against drugs"—and how feminists brought the two issues together in a dramatic campaign against Valium addiction in the 1970s. A final look at antidepressants shows that even the Prozac phenomenon owed as much to commerce and culture as to scientific wizardry. With a barrage of "ask your doctor about" advertisements competing for attention with shocking news of drug company malfeasance, Happy Pills is an invaluable look at how the commercialization of medicine has transformed American culture since the end of World War II.”
*      This book is important because the 1950’s right after WWII is when Psychiatry really took off.  I will be using this book for a history of what it used to be and how much it has increased today.
10) HORGAN, JOHN. "Are Psychiatric Medications Making Us Sicker?." Chronicle Of Higher Education 58.5 (2011): B4-B5. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “In this article the author discusses psychiatric medicines and examines the possibility that medical treatment for mental illnesses such as depression, bipolarity, schizophrenia, and anxiety disorder may do more harm than good. He comments on his research regarding the limited medical evidence regarding the effectiveness of medications such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), tricyclics, and monoamine oxidase inhibitors and the possibility of collusive behavior between the pharmaceutical industry and psychiatrists to promote the use of psychotropic drugs. He also analyzes research published in the book "Anatomy of an Epidemic" by Robert Whitaker regarding the negative effects of SSRIs and the attention-deficit disorder medication Ritalin.”
*      This is another article I believe I will look to more because it repeats the argument I will be trying to make in my paper.
11) Jackson, Catherine. "Diagnostic Disarray." Therapy Today 23.3 (2012): 4-8. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “The article reports the conflict that has been created by the decision of the American Psychiatry Association's proposed fifth revision of the "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders" (DSM-5). A main reason attributed for criticism of the draft is the application of psychiatric diagnoses to an even larger number of normal ranges of human emotions and behaviors. Two new diagnoses highlighted in DSM-5 are oppositional defiant disorder and premenstrual dysphoric disorder. INSET: If the symptoms fit.....”
*      The subject of the DSM-5 is very big in the medical community because it is what Psychiatrists use to diagnose illnesses they then prescribe psychotropic drugs for.
12) Making a Killing: The Untold Story of Psychotropic Drugging: A Documentary Film. 2000. DVD. Citizens Commission on Human Rights. 2000.
13) ---Psychiatry: An Industry of Death: A Documentary Film. 2010. DVD.
Summary: "Psychotropic drugs. It's the story of big money-drugs that fuel a $330 billion psychiatric industry, without a single cure. The cost in human terms is even greater-these drugs now kill an estimated 42,000 people every year. And the death count keeps rising. Containing more than 175 interviews with lawyers, mental health experts, the families of victims and the survivors themselves, this riveting documentary rips the mask off psychotropic drugging and exposes a brutal but well-entrenched money-making machine."
*      This documentary is what spiked my interest in the topic for my paper. I will watch it again and get more ideas.
14) Maj, Mario. "Financial And Non-Financial Conflicts Of Interests In Psychiatry." European Archives Of Psychiatry & Clinical Neuroscience 260.(2010): 147-151. Academic Search Premier. Web. 17 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “Conflict of interests occurs when a doctor is unduly influenced by a secondary interest (i.e., a personal incentive) in his acts concerning one of the primary interests to which he is professionally committed (the welfare of patients, the progress of science, or the education of students or residents). One specific variety of conflicts of interests has monopolized the attention of the scientific and lay press: the financial conflicts of interests arising from the relationships between doctors and drug companies. A large literature has described the many, sometimes subtle, ways by which a psychiatrist can be influenced in his prescribing habits or research activities by his relationships with the industry. Some empirical evidence is now available in this area. On the other hand, it has been pointed out that the current debate on this issue is sometimes 'affectively charged' or fails to take into account that the interests of patients, families and mental health professionals and those of the industry may be often convergent. Other types of conflicts of interests are beginning now to be discussed. There is evidence that the allegiance of a researcher to a given school of thought may influence the results of studies comparing different psychotherapeutic techniques, thus colliding with the primary interest represented by the progress of science. Political commitment is also emerging as a source of conflicts of interests. Financial and non-financial conflicts of interests are widespread in psychiatric practice and research. They cannot be eradicated, but must be managed more effectively than is currently the case.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
*      Conflicts of interest between the drug companies, the FDA, and the Doctors will be a large portion of my research paper. This is an important article for that.
15) Rudorfer, Matthew V., and Mi Hillefors. "Assessing Psychiatric Adverse Effects During Clinical Drug Development." Pharmaceutical Medicine - New Zealand 26.6 (2012): 363-394. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “Going forward, translational research holds the promise of better understanding of the biological and genetic underpinnings of these severe psychiatric adverse effects. Complementing this progress in the laboratory are advances in clinical and regulatory practice, most notably, the growing availability of electronic medical records and increasing harmonization of approach of drug regulatory bodies across countries. Together, these trends hold promise for a more complete appreciation of, and response to, threats posed to the benefit: risk of pharmacotherapy by medications with undesirable adverse effects, including those in the psychiatric as well as physical health spheres” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
16) Saniotis, Arthur. "Evolutionary And Anthropological Approaches Towards Understanding Human Need For Psychotropic And Mood Altering Substances." Journal Of Psychoactive Drugs 42.4 (2010): 477-484. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “Human addiction to psychotropic and mood altering substances is an ongoing international problem. While the phenomenon of psychoactive drug use has received considerable theoretical attention there need to be more comparative approaches into this area. Evolutionary and anthropological approaches for understanding human need for psychotropic and mood altering substances offer the reader various insightful angles for analyzing this phenomenon. While evolutionary approaches investigate the evolutionary behaviors and mechanisms of human ancestral psychotropic use, anthropological approaches emphasize the social and religious meanings of individual drug use. While each approach proffers different ideas, a comparative approach, which is utilized in this study, may provide a novel and invaluable insight for understanding human need for psychotropic and mood-altering substances.”[ABSTRACT FROM PUBLISHER] .
*      This Article is particularly interesting because it goes into the addiction people have today with “Needing” drugs for normal feelings basically.
17) Sharav, Vera Hassner. "Screening For Mental Illness: The Merger Of Eugenics And The Drug Industry." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 7.2 (2005): 111-124. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “The implementation of a recommendation by the President's New Freedom Commission (NFC) to screen the entire United States population--children first--for presumed, undetected, mental illness is an ill-conceived policy destined for disastrous consequences. The "pseudoscientific" methods used to screen for mental and behavioral abnormalities are a legacy from the discredited ideology of eugenics. Both eugenics and psychiatry suffer from a common philosophical fallacy that undermines the validity of their theories and prescriptions. Both are wed to a faith-based ideological assumption that mental and behavior manifestations are biologically determined, and are, therefore, ameliorated by biological interventions. NFC promoted the Texas Medication Algorithm Project (TMAP) as a "model" medication treatment plan. The impact of TMAP is evident in the skyrocketing increase in psychotropic drug prescriptions for children and adults, and in the disproportionate expenditure for psychotropic drugs. The New Freedom Commission's screening for mental illness initiative is, therefore, but the first step toward prescribing drugs. The escalating expenditure for psychotropic drugs since TMAP leaves little doubt about who the beneficiaries of TMAP are. Screening for mental illness will increase their use.” [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
18) Stein, David B., and Robert Foltz. "The Need To Operationally Define "Disease" In Psychiatry And Psychology." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 11.2 (2009): 120-141. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Abstract Summary: “A universally accepted operational definition for the term "disease" is not yet established in contemporary psychiatry. In clinical psychology and psychiatry, disease has been used indiscriminately. The term disease has been invoked (even when no systemic etiology or pathology has existed) to describe addictions, a cluster of bizarre symptoms, and to justify crude medically based treatments (e.g., electroshock, lobotomy, involuntary commitment, medication prescription). More recently, sophisticated machines such as CAT scans, PET scans, and MRIs have been used for questionable research conducted to try to identify supposed diseases, to justify the overuse of psychotropic drugs. Economic and industry interests have superseded scientific concerns. To establish scientific rigor in psychiatry and clinical psychology research, an operational definition of disease is proposed.”[ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
19) Sullivan, H. S. (2012). Conceptions of Modern Psychiatry: The first William Alanson White Memorial Lectures. Psychiatry: Interpersonal & Biological Processes, 3-17.
Abstract Summary: “The role of William Alanson White in the last four decades of American psychiatry was great indeed. To most of his students, the Professor was American psychiatry and a kindly benevolent father. In psychiatry he was a leader, a champion of progressive developments. He was a calm influence at the conference table and a wise counselor to those with whom he collaborated. In medicine, he was the foremost exponent of the doctrine of the Organism-as-a-whole. He was an integrator of constructive emergent in the field of the social sciences. He correlated divers scientific insights in the service of understanding human behavior. In the family, the community, and in the counsels of legislator and executive, he was a tireless proponent of the wise dissemination of psychiatry. His purpose and the purposes of psychiatry were one. Educator, collaborator, integrator, investigator humanitarian; he was a stimulus to great achievements, an ideal exemplinarian of the doctrine of service.”
20) United States National Institute of Mental Health. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 10 Apr 2013. Web. 23 Apr 2013.
Summary: This website is full of publications on my topic of Psychiatry and Psychotropic Drugs. I will refer a lot to this website.


Chapter 19: Designing Documents and Presentations & Chapter 20: Understanding Documenting Systems 04/24/13

Chapter 19: Designing Documents and Presentations
Bedford suggests considering the typical design characteristics associated with the type of document you’ve chosen.  Then adhering to the different characteristics will help you meet the expectations of your readers.  I can understand why this suggestion is so important. If your research paper does not feel and read as a research paper it can distract your readers from the point entirely of your paper. The important aspects of the design of your paper are; wide margins, readable fonts, and double spaced lines. Since our research paper is strictly following the MLA format, this portion does not seem to affect our current paper, but is good for future reference.
                This chapter does give good examples of MLA format and what to do.  The chapter then goes into how to write newspaper articles, design websites, and oral presentations; all of which do not pertain to our current paper, but will probably be needed later in our college career.
Chapter 20: Understanding Documenting Systems
This chapter goes over the different types of documentation systems there are such as MLA, APA, Chicago, and CSE. MLA is what is commonly used in all of the classes I have taken here at O.C. so far, but I have heard some of the Chemistry teachers like APA instead. It is good to have these references to use from Bedford for future use. The most important part of documentation systems is the format they want you to use for your paper (such as font size, margins, name, and header footer settings, etc.) and for your work cited. Each has a different method it will simply be important to train yourself to follow that method. On page 330 in Bedford there is a table (Table 20.1) that is and will be very helpful for the difference in work cited and in-text citation for the different documentation systems.

Chapter 7: Avoiding Plagiarism 04/24/13

The Bedford Researcher defines plagiarism as a form of intellectual dishonesty. “It involves either unintentionally using someone else’s work without properly acknowledging where the ideas or information came from (most common form of plagiarism) or intentionally passing off someone else’s work as your own (the most serious form of plagiarism).” (Bedford 121). Even though this is just a summary of a chapter I still decided to cite the document because this topic is so serious. I have never plagiarized anything on purpose but I cannot say that I never unintentionally did, for example forgetting to cite something properly, or reading something and later paraphrasing it without realizing what I did. That is why it is so important to keep track of your reading notes and thoughts so you can easily go back and check where you heard something. A good suggestion from Bedford that I actually use is to thoroughly check your paper, make sure work cited is perfect and that all the quotes are done and cited properly. I actually have to force myself to do this with every paper I do because I am terrible when it comes to anything related to work cited. Though I must say with all the labs and the book to follow properly now it has become a lot easier.
                Common knowledge would be any information that is widely known. The example given would be the Declaration of Independence was signed in 1776, and since everyone knows (or should know) that fact, you will not need to sight that document. Sometimes if you plan to publish your work you will need to ask permission from the writers you have quoted in your own work. While most writers allow you to cite some of their work without permission as long as it is for academic purposes. So basically it is on a case by case basis and check your sources for any copyright information carefully. This chapter was very helpful on what to do to avoid any type of intentional or unintentional plagiarism.

Monday, April 22, 2013

Chapter 11: Developing Your Thesis Statement 04/22/13

The Bedford basically says that a research paper is adding your contributions to a conversation about a topic and supporting your argument with different sources. I found this statement to be extremely helpful for writing my paper. It is simple and gets to the point.  The thesis statement is a critical part of your research paper, it is your guide to your paper and to you argument. After you have critically read and taking notes on your sources you can begin using those notes to support your argument. Your thesis is your most important idea or argument you want to convey to your readers. Before you decide on your thesis statement you Bedford says you should; Review your position statement, Review your notes, consider your purpose and role, and then reflect on your readers.
To begin your thesis you should go back to your notes and statements and look for any repetition or key phrases. There are different ways of explaining a position: Asking readers to learn something, asking readers to change their attitudes or beliefs, asking readers to take action. These suggestions from Bedford will be very helpful to be because thesis statements are generally my enemy along with work cited when it comes to writing a paper.  I will follow the suggestion to try and write a thesis from each position and pick the one that fits best with my topic. Also the more you keep your thesis focused the better. Table 11.1 will be extremely helpful to drafting my thesis statement.
                This chapter I think really digs into how to develop your thesis statement and is very helpful because your thesis statement is so important to your topic and your paper.

Saturday, April 20, 2013

Chapter 10: Searching for Information with Field Research Methods 04/20/13

In Chapter 10 Bedford says that publications (Books, articles, webpages, etc.) are not always the best types of sources because they offer “someone else’s interpretation of an event or an issue”.  Field research is often times considered one of the better options for a research writer because you get to understand a topic better first hand.  Doing field research can help you provide a new idea, argument or voice on your topic that may have not been established in any of your published research.  One of the suggested types of field research methods what do to an interview. And that an interview does not need to be face to face, it can be over the phone or even through email.
                Interviewing a person should have some thought really put into it. You can interview different types of people for the same topic. Bedford suggests interviewing different people who are affected by a topic to get their opinions on it. I really found this part interesting for my own topic because I know at least 5-6 people in my close friends who have been prescribed medication or told they have some sort of mental illness, when really they are just normal people with normal feelings.  Another suggestion is to write a script. This is particularly important to me when interviewing different people about the same subject, that way you can gage their answers and the differences in the answers differently.  I plan on doing something along these lines for my research paper now after reading this chapter I think it would really help my argument of over diagnosis in this country.  I can also ask fact and opinion questions which again will help support my arguments.  Another good idea will be to use a recording if I am doing an over the phone interview. Emails and text messages have a thread of conversation, while talking it is harder to properly take word for word notes during the interview.
                Another technique Bedford gives is observing. I think this would be a great idea for some topics, but for my research paper this would be more difficult because with anything in medicine it is always patient doctor confidentiality. So I would do more of an interview to get general statistics, and ask personal stories or opinions of anyone I knew who would be willing to share.  Personal opinions of the general public is good, because it helps to show what people really think is going on in the country. And to do this I might employ the last suggestion; Surveys. I work in a library, so I could ask other students to answer a small 3-5 question survey for me for a class if they wanted to. This could help me get some substantial information on what people think about Psychiatry and psychotropic drugs/industry.
So, to Review:
Different Field Research Methods:
1.       Inter views
2.       Observation
3.       Survey

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

In Class Lab: Incorporating Sources Effectively 04/16/13

1)      Quotation from one of your sources.

a.       James B. Gottstein, author of Ethical and Moral Obligations Arising from Revelations of Pharmaceutical Company Dissembling, plainly states “Psychiatrist should be in an uproar over the way they have been systematically misled.” (Gottstein 25)

b.      According to Professor David B. Stein of Virginia State University “A universally accepted operational definition for the term “disease” is not yet established in contemporary psychiatry.” (Stein 120)

2)      Compose 2 brief paragraphs each containing quotes from your 2 sources.

a.       The past and ongoing trials and investigations show that the pharmaceutical companies themselves have been paying the psychiatrist to prescribe more of their manufactured prescription drugs in order to make more money. This is quite the opposite of the “ethical code” doctors take an oath to follow.  In reference to new literature psychiatrist are require to follow, James B. Gottstein, author of Ethical and Moral Obligations Arising from Revelations of Pharmaceutical Company Dissembling, plainly states “Psychiatrist should be in an uproar over the way they have been systematically misled.” (25)

b.      Psychiatry has been around for well over a hundred years. And yet they still have no idea what or if something medical can cause mental illnesses. And therefore how to treat those said illnesses. According to Professor David B. Stein of Virginia State University “A universally accepted operational definition for the term “disease” is not yet established in contemporary psychiatry.” (120). It is then to be understood that unless there is a medical cause for a mental illness there should not be any medication prescribed that can affect a person’s body in anyway.

3)      Read Ch. 8 (See Previous Blog Post for Summary)

4)      Work Cited: 5 Sources
Barker, Phil, and Poppy Buchanan-Barker. "First, Do No Harm: Confronting The Myths Of Psychiatric Drugs." Nursing Ethics 19.4 (2012): 451-463. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Gottstein, James B. "Ethical And Moral Obligations Arising From Revelations Of Pharmaceutical Company Dissembling." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 12.1 (2010): 22-29. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Maj, Mario. "Financial And Non-Financial Conflicts Of Interests In Psychiatry." European Archives Of Psychiatry & Clinical Neuroscience 260.(2010): 147-151. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Sharav, Vera Hassner. "Screening For Mental Illness: The Merger Of Eugenics And The Drug Industry." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 7.2 (2005): 111-124. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
Stein, David B., and Robert Foltz. "The Need To Operationally Define "Disease" In Psychiatry And Psychology." Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry 11.2 (2009): 120-141. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.
5)      Image and Image Citation:
    
“New data on mental illness among U.S. youth”. Chart. Monitor on Psychology 42.2 (2011): 10. American Psychological Association. www.apa.org. Web. 16 April 2013.

Chapter 8: Searching for Information with Digital Resources 04/16/13

The Bedford says that it is no longer a problem on finding enough sources for a research project, but more finding the right source for a research project. One idea to find the “right type of source” is to use key phrases before you start searching for digital sources by brainstorming or clustering a list of key words to search for. You can also build on your research statement or thesis to search for more credible sources. This strategy will be very useful when looking up sources in the library database.
When researching on the web it is better to use more than one word searches to narrow down your results. Rather than doing one word searches and having it come back with over a million hits.  When looking up digital sources it is a good idea to prepare advanced searches to find better sources for your topic. The Bedford gives a table to follow Boolean Operators which let you search for key words. This table seems very helpful for research purposes. The rest of the chapter basically breaks down different search methods for different types of sources.

Monday, April 15, 2013

5 Sources for Research Paper with Source Evaluation Questions 04/15/13

Source 1: Toxic Psychiatry (Book)
1: Provide a Complete Citation for the Source:  Breggin, P. R. (1991). Toxic Psychiatry. New York: St. Martin's Griffin. In Text Citation: (Breggin 1991)
2. In what ways are the information, ideas and arguments in the source relevant to your research writing project?  Dr. Breggin’s book is all about his experiences in the field of Psychiatry since the 1950s before the big drug movement for mental illness and everything to follow. His arguments and research are sound therefore this book will be crucial to my research.
3. Is the line of argument in the source sound and well supported? In what ways can you use it in your project? Everything in this book is well supported. I can use the different stories and research to support my argument that Psychiatrist are basically corrupted by the pharmaceutical drug companies and the Doctors are doing more harm that any good to their patients.
4. What have you learned about the author and publisher that would lead you to accept, question or reject the line of argument presented in the source? The author of the book was a Harvard graduate and one of the leading and respected doctors in the Psychiatric specialty. The publisher is also very well-known and respected therefore I believe this book to be of great value.
5. In what ways does the publication date of the source affect your judgment of its usefulness for your project? The publication date does worry me some since it was written in 1991. But he provides a great detailed background of how he witnessed psychiatry becoming what it is today. It also shows that this problem was well known at the time it was published and is still going on today.
6. In what ways does the comprehensiveness of the source affect your judgment of its usefulness for your project? Dr. Breggin explains in a way that anyone who does not have a background in psych can understand. I was worried that some of these books would be above my level but it is really easy to follow.
7. In what ways does the genre of the source affect your judgment of its usefulness for your project? This genre is described as a “myth shattering expose”, therefore it is not a novel, or autobiographical type of book. It is a book that just lays the facts out there for people to read and decide how to go on from there.
8. In what ways could this source help you achieve your purpose and address the needs and interest of your readers? I think this source will help me explain the complicated relationships between the drug companies, FDA, Doctors and patients easily to show my readers how bad things have gotten, and how easily it would be to fix this situation and save lives at the same time.
9. How are you likely to use this source in your project?  So far from my reading of this book I think it will probably be my biggest “go-to” for my project. It is filled with a lifetime of personnel experiences of learning, helping, teaching, and practicing psychiatry.  Dr. Breggin’s profound knowledge on the subject really helps support why he does not believe in prescribing medications for mental illness and just how far down the rabbit hole psychiatry is compared to any other mental health practice.
Source 2: Happy Pills: From Miltown to Prozac (Book)
1. Herzberg, D. (2009). Happy Pills in America: From Miltown to Prozac. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. In Text Citation:   (Herzberg 2009)
2. Herzberg book is focusing more on the actual medications and how since their existence has drastically affected and changed our society.  I have just received the book today so I will have to dive more into it to get a better grasp on the subject matter.
3. One third of this book is notes and references to show just how well the information stated is supported. So I think, yes, this source is very well supported.
4. The author has many reviews of Journals for History and Medicine singing his praises for his book. Therefore with that much support I would have to think it is a trustworthy source.
5.  The publication date is fairly recent so it will help me with most recent arguments for my topic.
6. While I have not read very much into this book, the pictures of ad campaigns and charts and graphs will be vital in understanding what the author is trying to get across to the readers.
7. This genre is specifically aimed at the different types of drugs prescribed for different disorders. This will help me prove that the drugs do more harm than good to the patients because there is no proof that a disorder exists and there is proof that the drugs do cause harm to the brain etc. So this book will probably have me focus more on that than any other part of it.
8. This book will help support my topic that the doctors and FDA are in the pocket of the pharmaceutical companies.
9. I am very likely to use this source in my project because it is full of a wealth of knowledge pertaining to the types of medications/drugs used in psychiatry.
Source 3: Generation Rx: How Prescription Drugs Are Altering American Lives, Minds, and Bodies. (Book)
1. Critser, G. (2005). Generation Rx: how prescription drugs are altering American lives, minds, and bodies. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company. In Text Citation: (Critser, 2005)
2. Critser’s book is about the different pharmaceutical companies and their strategies legal or not to advertise and get their drugs out there. It also discussed how the people of America have begun feeling “entitled” to these drugs whether they are needed or not.
3. The book seems to be well supported; again I just received this one so I haven’t been able to read into it yet. I will mostly likely use this one to support my arguments about the drug companies themselves.
4. The author, Greg Critser, is a longtime chronicler of the modern pharmaceutical industry. His essays and columns on the subject have appeared in Harper’s Magazine, USA Today, The Wall Street Journal, and the Los Angeles Times just to name a few. Therefore it seems that he is well educated in the subject so his research should be true.
5. Again, the publication date is fairly recent so I feel I can trust the arguments made will still be valid.
6. Hopefully the book it easy to comprehend, If the text is not, I will not use it as much for my sources as I would if I completely understood everything in the book.
8. This book could help me a lot with providing insight to the pharmaceutical companies themselves and how they are ran.
9. I will most likely use this source along with the other 2 books as my main sources.
Source 4: Psychiatry Making a Killing (Documentary)
1.  Proper source to follow as I am still waiting for my copy of this documentary in the mail: Making a Killing: The Untold Story of Psychotropic Drugging (DVD)
2. This documentary is what created an interest for me in this topic. I had to watch it for another class. At the time I did not realize that it was produced by the CCHR, who are a scientology based group that believes psychiatry is the “root of all evil”. So while I now know it is a very biased documentary I still plan to use it to find the truths within it based on the doctors and stories behind it.
3. I believe most of the material in the documentary is sound and supported it is simply a matter of getting threw the distinct bias of the documentary and looking at it in a more scientific way to show the damage that is done to the “normal” people by the drugs and drug administration. Please do not get me wrong, I do believe there are people with mental illnesses that do need some medical intervention and in no way should they not be able to get the help that they need.
4. Again, the publisher is the CCHR, which makes this not only a documentary but propaganda. I will need to find the truths in the film.
5. (I still do not have the actual DVD yet). I believe that the publication date was made in the late 90s-Early 2000s so it stands to reason most of the information given is up to date for that time.
6. This source is very easy to comprehend and follow; it is dialed down to a level a child could understand. Again, it is finding the facts vs. the propaganda to evaluate the real problems.
7. The genre is meant to be a documentary but it is formed on a very biased opinion so it will be harder to use as a source, but not impossible.
8. This source is very easy to use to get the readers engrossed in the topic. It is what made me so interested in the topic of Psychiatry.
9. I will be using this as a source in my paper, but I will only use the factual evidence provided.

Source 5: “Concepts of Modern Psychiatry” (Lecture)
1. Sullivan, H. S. (2012). Conceptions of Modern Psychiatry: The first William Alanson White Memorial Lectures. Psychiatry: Interpersonal & Biological Processes, 3-17. In Text Citation (Sullivan 2012).
2. The source is relevant because it is a Lecture found in the OC Library’s database on Modern Psychiatry. And should provide a different view on today’s psychiatry verses the popular negative opinions on the subject.
3. This article is about psychiatry. I have not read the entire article yet, but there is an abundant number of notes on each page so I believe it is a well-supported argument.
4. Because this article is written by psychiatrist who believe and prescribe based on today’s psychiatric methodology I believe that I will use this article more on the premise on the idea psychiatrist believe they are doing it the right thing for their patients.
5. The publication date is only a year old therefore I think it will give me an up to date idea on the subject.
6. This article seems particularly harder to follow that the other sources I have. I will most likely have to go over and over it to truly comprehend what is being said.
7. The genre is an academic lecture, so I will have to read it and try not to see threw the different bias that is sure to be in the document. Again I will be using this as a template to form my argument against it.
8. This source could help me support my thesis based on the arguments made in it and to keep my paper interesting for my readers.
9. I hope to use this source a lot for my paper, but due to the comprehension factor, I might have to go into different sources to find another article to better form my argument against.

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Chapter 6: Managing Information and Taking Notes 04/10/13

                The Bedford says that no matter how narrow your research question is, you will most likely find a lot of relevant sources. Learning to manage the information you find and take proper notes then you will be able to save and organize your information better for your paper. This will also help you avoid plagiarism according to Bedford.
                First, you need to decide how to save and organize your printed information.  The chapter gives many different ideas on how to organize everything from basically clean chaos to binders and filling cabinets with labels. But once you choose an organization method you need to stick to it. For me, I will be using folders for my printed documents and a notebook with sources, and notes on my readings. Another tip from this section that if the document you printed out does not have the information you will need for your work cited. Write it on the document itself to save yourself time in the end.  Second, it directs you to create a way to save all of your digital information and organize it as well through file shares, etc.  Another Suggestion I found interesting is keeping a research log on your cell phone. Most phones these days have the capabilities of doing this and it is something everyone my age is never without so it makes perfect sense. I have already begun keeping a work cited source log, but the book suggests using bedfordreasercher.com to save bibliographic information about the sources for our papers.
                The taking notes section gives a lot of great suggestions for how to take notes. But the important one I noticed was that once you decide on a note taking method to stick to that method for the remainder of your paper.  Another important rule I noticed was that you must cite a source if you paraphrase something. Usually instead of paraphrasing I would simply go back and place direct quote in my paper because I was always afraid of plagiarism. I found this to be extremely helpful.  Another suggestion I will be using will be to “Classify Sources” because my paper will have a lot of sources with polarized views on the subject along with professional opinions on both medical and legal discussions, so this suggestion is the perfect solution for me.
I think this Chapter is one of the most important and crucial aspects to writing and thorough and enlightening research paper.

Chapter 3: Developing Your Research Question and Proposal 04/10/13

Chapter 3 in Bedford covers: How can I develop my research question?  And how can I create a research proposal?
A research question is something that helps you direct your research and what direction it is heading in. Otherwise you could be reading a very broad spectrum of ideas and opinions on the topic that might not be pertinent to your actual paper. One thing the book pointed out is that your question is not set in stone; you should consider it a “flexible guide” because as you learn more about your topic your question will probably change more often than not. And I know that is a habit of mine when doing a research paper. I always learn something new that can send my paper in a totally opposite direction than I intended on going in the first place.
Step 1 is to reflect on your writing situation. The Bedford suggests having more than one research question as you are developing your ideas for your paper, then narrowing it down as you go.  It also goes on to say that every writer has a set of biases as they begin their papers so I need to focus on trying to let go of those biases and be cognoscente of the fact that my biases are present and most likely will shape my paper in one form or another. Step 2 is to generate potential research questions: These questions can either be Information, History, Assumptions, Goals, Outcomes and Policies.  Some other types of questions help you engage in different thinking processes; Definition, Evaluation, Comparison/Contrast, Cause/Effect Analysis, Problem/Solution Analysis or Advocacy, Sequential Analysis, Inquiry, and Reporting. Step 3 is to craft questions that reflect your writing situations. The section of this chapter that I really found helpful was the questions on page 44-45. Step 4 is to select and refine your research question. You must choose the research question that seems most likely to go with your topic.
How can I create a research proposal? A research proposal is a formal presentation of your plan for your research writing project.  Bedford says that you need to include the following; Title page, an introduction, a review of literature, and explanation of how you will collect information, a project timeline, and a working bibliography. I find this portion particularly helpful because it will help keep me focused on what I need to write for my paper.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Tutorial: How do I evaluate a Web Site? 4/09/13


My Topic: The relationship between high diagnoses of mental illness, prescribed psychological drugs, the FDA, the drug companies and doctors relationships.

1.       It is an .org site; therefore it is a non-profit organization.
2.       The publisher is Citizens Commissions on Human Rights International (CHRR International). Their Mission Statement is “Mission Statement: The Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) is a non-profit, non-political, non-religious mental health watchdog. Its mission is to eradicate abuses committed under the guise of mental health and enact patient and consumer protections.” They are trying to protect the people and give information on who is paying the doctors that are prescribing their medicines and diagnosing them.
3.       There is no specific author for this article.
4.       It was last modified in 2013, so it is pretty recent. Also there is a lot of recent comments on the article.
5.       There are enormous amounts of evidence backing up the point of this article. They even reference court trials for the Doctors who were caught doing illegal activities with the drug companies.  I would easily be able to go more into detail researching the events they have cited in this article.
6.       There is an “About us” section which I could use to better research this organization to check its background and make sure it is a legitimate organization with a legitimate purpose.

Chapter 5: Evaluating Sources 04/09/13

The first general advice on this topic is to skim over a document to make a quick decision if it is credible and worth the time you will put into reading and citing it to use for your document. As our research paper this quarter had a 10 resource limit I find this section to be very important to determining what I should focus on. Relevance is very important when you use documentation.  The first suggestion in this chapter is to evaluate the evidence from the source you are thinking about using. Make sure it is the right kind of evidence, enough evidence, and ethical evidence. Also is it convincing? The second and third suggestion refers to the Author and the Publisher and making sure that they are knowledgeable about the topic and credible. In this day and age the two suggestions I just referred to are very important.
Section 5b really goes into that the most important part of evaluating electronic sources is; relevance and credibility. Anyone can write any mess and throw it on the internet as truth. Therefore it is very important to make sure every source you use is gives important information but most of all is credible.

Saturday, April 6, 2013

Chapter 4: Reading Critically 04/06/13

“Becoming critical readers” is something you hear over and over again in college, but I have never had someone really explain the meaning to me. Ch. 4 is all about critical reading. It says that critical reading is reading with an attitude and asking questions. I personally found the idea “writing your reactions and questions in the margins” to be very helpful.  A research paper is all about answering a question. With critical reading you can focus on what are the answers to your specific question and helps the writer focus more. Critical reading for your topic is also crucial to turning your research question into a thesis statement. This is particularly helpful to me because I am forever stuck when trying to cram all the different things I want to say into my thesis, and I will be using this to better equip myself for the upcoming task of this research paper.  It also suggests that once you have decided your research question and began your primary thesis statement then you are ready to read actively. Meaning that if you have no idea what the point is you are going for in your paper how can you possible read actively to support that point?
                Personally I think this chapter was very helpful in finally explaining in detail what the whole “reading critically was all about”. I now have a better understanding to go forward and first ask my question, do some research, find the conversations, broad theme, and arguments for my topic. Then I will develop my thesis and go into actively reading for my research paper. (all along keeping my research log to track all of my documentation.)